Report from the LIBE Committee Delegation on the Visit to Ceuta and Melilla
mise en ligne :01 02 2006 ( NEA say… n° 03 )
Commission des libertés civiles, de la justice et des affaires intérieuresBrussels, 24 January 2006 (Rapporteur: Ms Ewa KLAMT)
1. Report on the visit
A delegation of 17 MEPs, 14 from LIBE and 3 from DROI (see list in Annex I) travelled to Ceuta and Melilla to visit the borders and the CETI (Immigrants Temporary Holding Centre) from 7 to 9 December 2005.
The scope of the delegation was to check the implementation of Council Directive 2003/9/EC laying down minimum standards for the reception of asylum seekers, and to get information from the Spanish authorities about the events which started on 28 August 2005 and which resulted in the deaths of migrants who were trying to jump the fence that divides the cities of Ceuta and Melilla from Morocco.
Prior to visiting the two autonomous Spanish towns, the EP delegation met the Secretary of State for Immigration and Emigration, Mrs Consuelo RUMI, in Madrid.
In Melilla the delegation had a meeting with the Government representative, Mr. José Fernández CHACON and with the President of the Town, Mr Juan José IMBRODA. In Ceuta the EP delegation met the Government representative, Mr Jerónimo NIETO and the President of the Town, Mr Juan Jesús VIVAS.
In Madrid, Ceuta and Melilla the delegation also had the opportunity to meet a considerable number of NGOs (see the list in Annexe II).
The visit received good media coverage.
A. Summary of the intervention of the Secretary of State Consuelo RUMI
The Secretary of State Mrs Consuelo RUMI made a broad presentation on the situation of migration in Ceuta and Melilla and explained the facts surrounding the events which occurred from 28 August 2005. Her intervention could be summarised as follows:
- Illegal migration from sub-Saharan Africa in Ceuta and Melilla is not a new phenomenon (it already started in the 90s) but it has risen sharply recently, in a large-scale and coordinated way.
- The efforts of Morocco and Spain to patrol the coasts of the Canary Islands and the Mediterranean Sea have shifted the migration pressure from there to Ceuta and Melilla's land borders. Due to increased co-operation between Spanish and Moroccan authorities as well as the application of the S.I.V.E. (surveillance) System, the number of illegal immigrants reaching the Spanish coasts (Canary Islands and Mainland) from Africa by boat has decreased by 25% this year and by 18% last year. In the Canary Islands the number of "pateras" (boats) decreased by 44% this year.
- Spain and Morocco have already a bilateral readmission agreement since 1992. Morocco is mainly a transit country, and the real problem is the migration pressure from Africa to Europe. Ceuta and Melilla are on the EU's most southerly border.
- Regarding the events which occurred between August and October resulting in the deaths of at least 11 people, Mrs RUMI said that the Spanish authorities had made an investigation and found that the Spanish Guardia Civil was not responsible for these deaths. Nevertheless the judicial investigations are on going.
- After the events the Spanish Government took a series of measures, including the reinforcement of border controls by the police and custom guards, the allocation of 3 million Euro (1,5 million for each town) to help the towns, and closer cooperation with the Moroccan authorities, in particular to clear the border of vegetation in order to better control the territory near the fence.
- The Government also allocated a fund for non-accompanied minors with 1,7 million Euro in Ceuta and 2,3 million Euro in Melilla, as well as a reception, integration and education fund with 442.000 Euro in Ceuta and 592.000 Euro in Melilla.
- Regarding the case last October of the 73 persons, some of them asylum seekers according to UNHCR, who had been arrested in Melilla and taken from Algeciras to Tanger in Morocco. Mrs RUMI said that among them there where no asylum seekers.
- To a question concerning the possible "pull effect" of the Spanish regularisation of migrants, the Secretary of State answered that the 500.000 people regularised are now tax payers and no longer in the irregular market. She talked of an "escape effect" from poverty and hunger.
B.Visit to the Centres (CETI) of Ceuta and Melilla
Management of the centres
In Melilla the CETI has a capacity of 480 people. On 6 October 2005 1,650 people were housed in the CETI. Now some camping tents (10 military tents + 20 tents for families) have been added. The number of personnel has doubled in the last months.
In Ceuta the CETI has a capacity of 512, up to a maximum of 700 places. There is a smaller problem here than in Melilla.
The CETI are not detention centres, they are Temporary Holding Centres and are under the responsibility of the Ministry of Employment and Social Affairs (the detention centres are under the responsibility of the Interior Ministry). The migrants and asylum seekers are free to leave the CETI during the day. They have to come back in the evening at 23.00 and they need authorisation from the Director of the Centre if they want to leave for more then 24 hours.
The stay in the Centres should be for up to three months, for both migrants and asylum seekers. The management of the centres, according to the centres rules may propose the extension of the stay of the beneficiaries only once. In fact a lot of people said that they where there for more than 3 months. The centres provide a good coverage of the basic needs of the migrants, including accommodation, health care, education, legal assistance. The centre’s inmates had access to legal aid and interpreters, and their religious beliefs were respected.
Families are kept together. Every room lodges 6 people normally, at the moment up to 8 people, though more people are lodged in every tent. Rooms are cleaned by a professional cleaning company once a week. The washing of personal clothing is the responsibility of the people residing in the Centres. There is a TV and entertainment room, a nursery, a medical centre, as well as Spanish classes. In Ceuta there is also a library and a computer room.
Within the CETI other activities are organised, such as informative activities regarding the residents' legal and social situation, as well as entertainment and sport activities in collaboration with the NGOs.
The general impression of the EP delegation is that the management and the living conditions in the CETIs were very good. Everything seemed well organised and the atmosphere there was calm and at ease. The delegation also had the impression that the centres were not "disguised" because of the EP visit.
There are four categories of people in the CETIs:
1. Asylum seekers: they represent a small percentage of the people in the centres. One of the reasons is the fact that Spain is apparently not the final destination of the majority of the people entering Ceuta and Melilla. People do not want to be registered in Spain as asylum seekers and prefer to be sent to the mainland and disappear to become illegal workers in Spain or elsewhere. According to some NGOs the other reason is that only few asylum requests are accepted by the Spanish authorities, (in 2004 less then 3%).
2. Economic migrants who will be returned to the country of origin: when there is a readmission agreement between Spain and the country of origin of the migrants, these migrants are sent back. This is the reason why for example people coming from Sri Lanka (which concluded a readmission agreement with the EU) normally say that they come from India. India does not accept its migrants back.
3. Economic migrants who will be expelled from the Spanish territory: the majority of migrants belong to this category. Cooperation with sub-Saharan countries is very weak, with the exception of Nigeria, so people cannot be sent back to the country of origin. In these cases the Spanish authorities transfer the migrants to the mainland and ask them to leave the Spanish territory within 5 days. It is clear that these people become illegal immigrants in Spain or elsewhere in the European Union. The Spanish authorities are aware of this problem. Some of the migrants are transferred to detention centres in mainland.
4. Economic migrants accepted as legal migrants: very few migrants are accepted as legal migrants and transferred to Mainland.
Statements by the migrants
All the migrants to whom the Members of the delegation had the occasion to talk with seemed to be happy with the treatment in the CETI and happy to be there. They all think that the worst part of their trip to Europe is over. Most of the people from Sub-Saharan countries (Mali, Gambia, Guinea, Cote d'Ivoire, Ghana, Sudan, Liberia, Mauritania, Nigeria and Guinea Bissau) come to Ceuta and Melilla by jumping the fences and they are self-organised. They took between two to three years to arrive in the Spanish territory from their countries, spending normally up to eight months waiting in the forest around Ceuta and Melilla.
Figures indicate an increase of migrants from South East Asia, especially from India and Bangladesh. They come mainly by plane and by boat from their countries and then they cross the border not from scaling the fences, but with the help of gangs of human traffickers. People from Algeria and Morocco are also present in the CETIs. They also come via human traffickers. Women and children do not jump the fences, and in several occasions they have been found in Moroccan territory and accepted into the CETIs for humanitarian reasons.
The majority of the people interviewed by the MEPs said that Spain was not their country of destination.
C.Visit to the Borders of Ceuta and Melilla
Technical situation of the borders
The external land border of Ceuta and Melilla is composed of double fences 7,8 km and 10,5 km long, respectively. The outer fence now has, after the latest events, a height of 6 metres (before the events it had a height of 3/3,5 metres). The inner fence reaches 6 metres as well. Both fences are equipped with barbed wire, fixed cameras for video surveillance, microphone cables and an infra-red surveillance system. Between the two fences there is a 2 metre asphalted road, accessible to motorbikes of the Guardia Civil. Along the fences there are doors to pass from Spanish to Moroccan territory. According to several NGOs the doors on the fences are used by the Guardia Civil to expel migrants who have climbed over the outer fence.
The Guardia Civil is operational 24 hours a day. After the latest events, helicopters are used for further surveillance.
In total, 331 policemen and 676 Guardia Civil officers are deployed in Melilla, and 316 policemen and 626 Guardia Civil officers in Ceuta. In Ceuta the delegation noticed the presence of military forces also.
The EP delegation's impression is that the border control is no longer a problem and the borders are now secured so that people can now hardly cross the fences.
The EP delegation expressed its concern about the legal status of the territory within the two fences. According to the Spanish authorities, these two fences (the outer and the inner) have to be considered as a single obstacle and they are both in Spanish territory Several NGOs, including the UNHCR and Amnesty International, consider that once the migrants have jumped the outer fence, because they are in Spanish territory, they should be granted the possibility to ask for asylum.
Events of August / October 2005
The attempt by the migrants to illegally cross the fences has been described in detail both by the Guardia Civil official and by the NGOs. The groups of Sub-Saharan persons gather at daytime in the forest near the border, sometime for periods up to 8 months. When the people reach a "critical mass" of a few hundred people start the attempt to climb the fences using self-made wooden ladders. Normally people are divided into three groups: one to attract the attention of the Guardia Civil and one other group, in a different place, jumped over the fence, while the third group was holding the ladders for them. These attempts are self-organised by the migrants and well coordinated.
The EP delegation received contradictory information on the incidents occurring from August to October 2005 in Ceuta and Melilla. The Government authorities and the NGOs had a different view on the number of casualties, on the number of people who tried to jump the fences, on who is responsible for the shootings, and on the presumed violence perpetrated by the Guardia Civil.
The Moroccan authorities, after these tragic events, are now controlling the borders more effectively. The EP delegation is looking forward to see how the 40 million Euro the European Commission had allocated to help Morocco face the humanitarian situation will be used.
The EP delegation appreciated the great cooperation offered by the Spanish authorities during the visit, both from the central governmental and the local authorities.
The EP delegation considers that the situation in Ceuta and Melilla cannot be considered an emergency any more. The EP delegation appreciated the efforts made by the Spanish national authorities, those of the autonomous cities of Ceuta and Melilla, the security forces and the citizens of Ceuta and Melilla, to face the recent crisis, including the humanitarian efforts made to help the people who crossed the fences. The Moroccan authorities are cooperating better with the Spanish authorities and the borders are now completely under control. The situation in the centres is quite difficult due to the large number of people at present, but it will improve considering that the flux of migrants has decreased considerably.
The EP delegation believes that the problem has switched from the EU borders to the Moroccan territory. Further inquires have to be conducted to check the situation in Morocco.
The EP delegation would like to ask to the Spanish authorities:
1. to clarify the legal status of the migrants found in the territory between the two fences.
2. to report on the results of the inquiries on the casualties which occurred during the events between August and October.
3. to report on the results of the inquiries regarding the violence exercised against migrants, as denounced by Medecins sans frontières.
4. to provide more information about the implementation of the readmission and cooperation agreement with Morocco.
5. to clarify the situation of the people who are sent to the mainland to be expelled and who then in fact become illegal workers in Spain and Europe.
The EP delegation would like to ask to the European Commission to report to the European Parliament about the controls in operation concerning the use of European funds in third countries.
Annexe II: Liste des ONG qui vont rencontrer la Délégation
Rencontre avec les ONG à Madrid
- ACCEM (Association espagnole experte d'immigration et refugiés): Mme Julia Fernández et M. Enrique Barbero.
- Amnesty International: Mme Virginia Alvarez, Responsable des relations institutionnelles et Politique Intérieur d'Amnesty International, Espagne and Mrs Yolanda Román.
- Croix Rouge: M. Carlos CAPATAZ, Directeur des interventions sociales en Espagne.
- Médecins sans frontières: Carlos Ugarte, Coordinateur général de la mission en Espagne.
- UNHCR: Mme Debbie Elizondo, Deputy to the Representative for HCR Spain.
Rencontre avec les ONG à Melilla
- Asociacion Pro Derechos Humanos de Melilla (APDHM): M. José Alonso.
- CEAR (Comisión Española de Ayuda al Refugiado): M. Francisco Javier Arias.
- Melilla ACOGE: M. Armando Andrés.
- PRODEIN (Asociación pro derechos de la infancia): M José Palazón Osma.
Rencontre avec les ONG à Ceuta
- ACEMIGRA: M. Gonzalo Sanz, Président.
- Cruz Blanca:
- Cruz Roja: M Leon Bendaya, Président.
- Elin: Hermana Paula.
- Médecins sans frontières: Javier Gabaldón, de MSF basé à Rabat, au Maroc.
- SOS Racisme: Mme Helena Maleno, qui collabore avec SOS racisme au Maroc et qui travaille dans les camps au Maroc.
- Halte aux idées reçues en matière d’immigration !
Elections législatives du 30 novembre en Moldavie :compte rendu de la réunion de la Commission AFET du Parlement européen en association avec la Délégation de la commission de la coopération parlementaire UE/Moldavie